Currently baking out of Baked by Matt Lewis and Renato Poliafito

I think these brownies are the thing that started all the buzz surrounding this bakery, and by extension, this book. Oprah made them one of her “favorite things,” and America’s Test Kitchen and the Today Show awarded these brownies top honors (brownie tester – now there’s a job I could get behind). How could I not make this recipe?

Was I wowed? Blown out of the water? Made to feel insignificant and puny? No. In fact, I really hated these brownies. Hated them. Not the recipe (easy to follow). Not the flavor (deep and chocolatey). Not the texture (moist and fudgy). No, I hated these brownies because I couldn’t get them to cut cleanly. If you look closely at the picture, you’ll see all the ragged edges and the chunks gouged out of the sides.

Stupid brownies.

Nitpicking aside, these brownies are pretty good, and I liked them better as they aged. The recipe is straightforward, calling for flour, cocoa powder, dark chocolate, butter, sugar and eggs. Instant espresso powder and vanilla give the chocolate some depth. Everything is mixed by hand, and the only tricky part is not overbaking these brownies. Next time I make these, I’ll line the pan with parchment and refrigerate the brownies before cutting them.